This was an appeal from a Single Judge holding that, for a vessel to be arrested as a sister ship under s 5(1)(a) of the Admiralty (Jurisdiction and Settlement of Maritime Claims) Act 2017 (the Act), common ownership is required and that common management by a ship manager is insufficient to attract the jurisdiction of the Court. It was further held that a maritime lien for wages under s 9(1)(a) of the Act should be in respect of the vessel where such employment was undertaken and where the claim arose.
On appeal, the appellant conceded that its claim did not arise from a maritime lien. However, the appellant contended that by reason of ss 4(1)(o) and (p) of the Act [which cover wages and disbursement claims], a claim arose against the first defendant vessel, given that the second defendant, Star Voyages Shipping Services LLC, was also working as its manager. The appellant further submitted that s 5(2) of the Act [providing for sister ship jurisdiction] was not limited to the vessel in respect of which the second defendant was acting as a manager, and that an order of arrest could be made in respect of any other vessel for the purpose of providing security for a maritime claim arising under ss 4(1)(o) and (p) of the Act.
The appellant argued that the test to be applied under s 5 of the Act had been clearly elucidated by a Single Judge of the Bombay High Court in Siem Offshore Redri AS v Altus Uber (CMI377), in which a distinction was drawn between the vessels which can be classified as the contract vessel/offending vessel, and any other vessel, namely, the securing vessel. In an appropriate case, the securing vessel could be arrested for the purpose of providing security for a maritime claim.
The respondent submitted to the contrary that an action in rem for arrest of a ship would not lie against a ship owned by a person who is not responsible for payment of the claim, as held by the Supreme Court in Sunil B Naik v Geowave Commander (CMI183), where a clear distinction was drawn between the beneficial ownership of a ship and the charterer of a ship. The Court categorically stated that in the interest of international comity, though India was not a signatory to the Arrest Convention 1999, the principles of the same were being followed and applied to appropriate situations to determine whether a 'maritime claim' as understood in the international context had arisen, and whether it warranted the arrest of the vessel. Reference was also made to Owners and Parties Interested in MV Nereus Progress v Om Freight Forwarders Ltd (CMI2875), which explained the scope, ambit and extent of applicability of the arrest of a vessel, which may be a sister ship or a securing vessel.
Held: Appeal dismissed.
The claims relating to the crew members pertain to three vessels, none of which is the first defendant vessel. The owners of the three vessels have no commonality of interest with the first defendant vessel. Moreover, the owners of those vessels have not been impleaded as parties. This constitutes a fatal defect.
Section 5(e) of the Act permits the arrest of a vessel in respect of a claim against the ship's manager, provided that the claim is secured by a maritime lien as provided under s 9. There is no maritime lien here. However, the Act also permits admiralty jurisdiction in personam, which is subject to s 7, and is exercisable only in respect of maritime claims falling within s 4(1)(a)-(w). As no maritime claim arises under s 4(1)(o) and (p) of the Act, these provisions cannot be pressed into service.
The judgments relied on by the appellant all relate to demise charters. The appellant is not a demise charterer, but is only a crew supplier who claims to have entered into an agreement to supply crew to the vessels managed by the second defendant. A crew supplier who has a contractual arrangement with a ship's manager does not stand on a similar footing as a demise charterer qua the owner of the vessel.